
I'm a big fan of Michael Mann. All Miami Vice-related criticism aside, that guy has crafted some of the cooles shootouts I've seen since playing the Bunker level in GoldenEye '64. His latest project - the Jonny Depp-starring Public Enemies - is certainly no exception; though definitely not his best (The Insider is still one of my all time faves), Enemies is an engaging and surprisingly humorous glimpse into the life of notorious bank robber and apparent badass of the century, John Dillinger.
What Works: This one's obvious. As always, Depp is very good as Dillinger, bringing us a character who is equal parts vulnerable, maniacal, and amusingly charismatic, all while sporting a slick 1930s "hipster" accent. He's certainly not perfect, and there are definitely moments where it feels like he's phoning it in, but in the end, if you don't see this movie for any other reason, just go to watch Johnny Depp do his thing. I truly hate him for how likable he is.
What Doesn't Work: This one might be up for debate, but I wasn't feeling Marion Cotillard as Dillinger's girlfriend, Billie Frechette. While she's definitely a great actress in many respects, she just doesn't fit into her role in this one. Every time she's on screen, her accent shows through, and it sometimes detracts from the dramatic effect of her dialogue during important moments. That being said, her relationship with Dillinger still carries a great deal of depth and believability, and she also earns brownie points for being able to multitask (she's hot, naked, and inside a bathtub at the same time. Now that's acting, folks).
What Works: Hand-held cameras. Mann uses them, and I love them. Every sequence, especially those that consist of Dillinger breaking out of prison (that's right...there's more than one), is infused with a sense of urgency and movement that keeps the film fast-paced and engaging, even during the most expository scenes.
What Doesn't Work: HD cameras. I know it's weird, but digital cinematography nowadays is becoming way too perfect. The picture in this movie is so clear that sometimes you can actually see the makeup on characters' faces, and for some reason I'd just rather believe that bank robbers don't put on makeup before pulling off heists (unless they happen to wear smiley-shaped facial scars, in which case it's totally forgivable).
What Works: Two words...shoot outs. I'm serious man, the gunfights in this movie are the kind that make you cover your mouth and yell, "Oh, shit!" while inadvertently kicking the seat in front of you. I don't know if guns can actually cause people's chests to burst open like that, but if they can, then 50 Cent is a liar and we should stop supporting substandard mainstream music by purchasing his albums.
On The Fence: Christian Bale. I could go either way here...personally, I didn't have a problem with his performance as FBI hotshot Melvin Purvis, but then again, I was going to be happy no matter what (as long as he didn't use the Batman voice again...his John Connor may as well have been Bruce Wayne's idiot twin brother). His role in this film isn't necessarily huge, although it's definitely important and provides an ample amount of suspense for the "cat and mouse" narrative that Mann is creating. Some people in the theater said they liked him, others said they didn't. Personally, I just hate him because he's married to Sibi Blazic, who clearly would be interested in me if she didn't have him standing in the way.
What Works: The guy sitting next to me in the theater. This dude was four feet tall, wore a tuxedo, called himself Mr. Diamond (I'm not kidding), and intermittently yelled things like, "Oh, that mother fucker's dead!" whenever somebody died. I highly recommend seeing a movie with this guy if you ever get the chance.
All In All: Public Enemies is a good film. Not great, but definitely good. At two and a half hours, it moves along quickly and never feels tedious. Filled with decent performances, fresh direction, gorgeous production design, and a great deal of well-placed humor, it's definitely a refreshing break from the mindless summer action fare we're all used to.
Overall Rating: 7/10

